Who killed Bin Laden ?

May 2, 2011, 01H00 PKT 15H30 EST — Bilal Town, Abbottabad, Pakistan.


Version 1.

The two trained and experienced US Special Forces DEVGRU commandos, better known as SEAL Team 6, crept up the stairs in the glow from their Night Vision goggles. Reconnaissance had been perfect, and it was known that not one of the four men had night vision goggles.

A head peeped around a doorway.

The point man blocked his respiration and squeezed the trigger of his suppressed H&K 416 assault rifle.


Two others pumped in several more rounds into the body.

Version 2.

The point man missed.

The number two dove and rolled, came up facing Bin Laden pushing a woman in front of him, and put rounds into the target.

In both versions, Ben Laden apparently died without a fight or a whisper.

During his lifetime he overawed the world and hurled defiance at the most powerful superpower in history. The Superpower’s commandos mythicized by Hollywood and on Television had to be provided with an address and adequate transport before they could live upto the legends spun around them.


 So it was a three-part operation: hunt and locate, transport successfully and then execute the Presidential Executive Order.

Without the success of the first two parts of the operation, the final part would have remained a theoretical exercise buoyed by hope. The CIA found the address and the 160th Special Operations Aviation Regiment ensured stealthy arrival above the target.

Then the commandos did their job.

Professionals under contract, they flit silently in the shadows of strategic mechanisms, their lives depending on silence and invisibility. And they put their lives on the line with faith that their superiors and the nation they serve and protect will look after them.

A priori, a fair bargain but one which the current public squabble of who killed Mr. Bin Laden has brought under scrutiny.

In a contractual relationship, however, if one of the parties feels that the other has breached the legal or moral contract, it may seek redress of grievances by chosen, legal means. America’s silent warriors who feel they have been let down by their superiors have recourse to justice through the legal system.



By going public, the current spat between two former DEVGRU operators has reduced their latest known accomplishment to tabloid feed.

Since two wrongs don’t make a right, and revealing who killed Bin Laden breaches national security, challenging that claim in public reduces legend to farce.

A lose-lose situation for all concerned parties.

Before America’s vaunted Seals become an international laughing stock, the US government should take strong and immediate measures to ensure that compensation for their warriors’ services is institutional, immediate, publicized and well beyond mere semantics. At the same time, a special in-camera court needs to be constituted to hear and redress grievances of Special Forces operators.

Another Presidential Executive Order in addition to the one that sent these men to retrieve their nation’s prestige could satisfactorily solve the matter, were the Administration to find it as expedient as the one that launched Operation Neptune Spear.


  1. Gill Jee,I have gone through this article. In this connection just today I read this article. One may not agree with Greg in totality but some of his observations are very strong. I am sure if you have already gone through you will find it interesting. This is the link. http://www.paulcraigroberts.org/2014/11/07/another-fake-bin-laden-story-paul-craig-roberts/ Brotherly,QRS

    Date: Sun, 9 Nov 2014 17:43:17 +0000 To: qrs.94@hotmail.com


  2. Qaiser Jee, I followed the link with much interest, and had actually already read it. I remain sceptical for two reasons. Firstly, I don’t think the Americans are really clever enough to be able to pull this off. Secondly, if they did manage to rustle up the requisite talent (which they do have) it would require too much personnel involvement and interdepartmental cooperation to ensure against a press leak /s, something in which Washington is known to excel!
    Also, a weak point in the theory is the date of Bin Laden’s purported death: what did Bush have to gain by keeping it secret? And if so, why has not a Republican leak trumped up Obama’s achievement on the backs of a bunch of US Navy Warrant Officers who are then pushed aside while politicians strut on their stages?


  3. I also remember the passionate anger the Pakistani government exhibited after the attack, including the arrest and conviction of the doctor who helped the Americans find Bin Laden. Along with that, the Taliban’s continuing retribution aimed at health workers working to eradicate polio would indicate they also bore a substantial grudge that indicates a major injury to their cause due to the Abbottabad incident. Also, I don’t remember Al Qaida, Taliban, or Pakistani government sources denying that Bin Laden was killed in Abbottabad. It would be strange, indeed, if all three wouldn’t seize a chance to embarrass the Americans by revealing a fraud.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s