Uncategorized

India: The First Soft Power

The Durga Vahini women’s movement limited to two districts of India is part of that nation’s latest three-hundred year old Hindu revival. The Canadian filmmaker Nisha Pahuja’s quest to make a documentary on this movement finally ended in success. Writing for the BBC, she raises questions but expresses no alarm at this movement, based on pride and history — The World Before Her https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=umjDyRaikqQ  and http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-29798148).

The more one studies India’s history, the more it eludes one’s grasp, retreating constantly into the mists of time in a tantalizing dance. This mother lode of all that is Indo-European can stake its claim on the basis of holding the archives. Other components of and claimants to Indo-European roots only have oral history on their side, but India has the Vedas – sacred documents dated from between 1800BC to 3000BC, or even earlier.

https://encrypted-tbn3.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSxAz1NLs_qBa5A921-5AlCVrcODqjmgT8J7DNBg0mx5l0c4xGz

The total time span allotted to Indian history is so wide that were a subject called The Rise and Fall of Indian Civilization be introduced in academia, it would fall flat on its face. Indian civilization demands the plural, despite its continuing integral core. It expanded and receded several times, the components cohabiting comfortably with each other’s characteristics.

http://ptdeepali.files.wordpress.com/2012/12/lothal.jpg?w=640

 One of the most remarkable features of this civilization is its influence which stretched from Macedonia to the limits of East Asia without any evidence of hard power projection. India can bask in its status as a pioneer of Soft Power.

That finesse did not stop other civilizations from penetrating India’s refined screen to raid, loot and settle as minority rulers over much of its territory.

 

http://www.indohistory.com/images/medieval/mahmud_ghaznavi_conquests.jpghttp://static.guim.co.uk/sys-images/Guardian/Pix/pictures/2012/11/5/1352139688017/British-Empire-Throughout-008.jpg

The last ones to do so failed to integrate, were unable to settle and had to leave sixty seven years ago, leaving behind a free press and the cherished structure of parliamentary democracy.

The sheer force and prestige of Nehru’s personality dragged India through its period of socialism, but since its heyday there has been a turnaround. The most positive result of that is the continuing economic growth and progressing health and literacy rates despite the population increase since 1947.

Famine, rife under the Mughals and the British, has disappeared.

India is coming back into its own.

On the flip side, some Indians, basking in their new-found independence, seem to be taking the occasion to show that they are not softies. That they aren’t is an opinion buoyed by the reputation of the Indian Army for efficiency, not to speak of its millennia-old battle record. Militant groups and movements appear to be challenging world-wide extremist obediences in a race for each to prove that they’re the toughest on the block.

The Durga Vahini just might end up being one such movement, the female equivalent of the Bajrang Dal and part of the Vishva Hindu Parishad. The stated purpose is to involve more women in a Hindu revival through physical, mental and knowledge development in order to involve them in social services.

Considering India’s population of 1.252 billion, there are only about 8000 women involved in Durga Vahini. The movement is more local than national and, in general, most Indian Hindus have no hang-ups about settling scores with remnants of erstwhile minority rulers. Shouldn’t have any, in principle. Not after the last Hindu revival.

In the 18th century, the Marathas, by becoming the pre-eminent power in India effectively eclipsed the effete Mughals of that time, engendering a Hindu revitalization that continues to grow in most desirably impressive directions.

https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcQYG HElO7ENOkptBPbArAgYSCXv85vsuTaeZ7VjOWiApEmFFNRzw

It is confidently hoped that this balance will be maintained in a world where perceptions and soft power have superseded the old hard power, as obsolete as a nuclear weapon!

The world’s soft power pioneer is no doubt aware of this.

Many others are!

http://qz.com/271585/from-the-buddha-to-bollywood-to-bpos-a-brief-history-of-indias-soft-power/

Asian and White school results in the United Kingdom

https://encrypted-tbn2.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcS1hLhW98TEaF-dLNf1MraQJ4kYx7cKZu_QI6C6VQevZx_wNo0Pag

On November 12, Nihal, my favourite BBC Asian Network DJ got more of my attention than usual. I learned that children of Indian immigrants in the UK obtain the highest GCSE scores. That started me thinking, and for a change it didn’t hurt – well, maybe just a little.

The two-nation theory is believed to have, among other things, led Muslims to demand their severance from the rest of India by creating Pakistan. Mission accomplished, the theory often carries more weight in its political rather than historical context.

http://njisacf.files.wordpress.com/2009/02/wagah.jpg?w=320&h=389

However much Muslims of Pakistan may be tempted to graft their historical cultural roots on their belief system and end up in a Middle-Eastern state of Semitic mental limbo, the lure of the Indo European macro culture is as irresistible as it is undeniable. More so when they realize that the response from the Middle East is disproportionate to the initiative.

So the distinction between the contemporary application of the two-nation theory and the reality of the historical Indo-Euroean roots is a yo-yo comet leaving a zig-zag trace.

And there things stood until Nihal unwittingly landed on this comet to set my head spinning.

So I spent some time in space and here’s what I found from reputable sources such as, among others, the BBC’s Education Correspondent and the Centre for Crime and Justice Studies.

http://www.crimeandjustice.org.uk/resources/primary-and-secondary-education-and-ethnic-penalty

The progress rate of British Pakistani children might outstrip that of their white and British Indian peers, but a lead of thirteen points is not a lead of three plus one equals four as Einstein would have made it and ended up with another atomic split.

Poor results are also explainable by permanent exclusion. The rate of British Pakistanis at 0.05% also exceeds the almost 0% of British Indians although it lags honorably behind the nearly 01% of White British — funny, I wanted to write British White, but it kind of ended up reminding me of the latest upgrade in a teeth whitener.

https://encrypted-tbn1.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSbHeVcUle5TIObaBaQT9zCdT1ZfArtRVCb0gyZtxEl2Ou5eunqAA

Which means, the children of Indian and Pakistani parents are more British since they are British first and not second even if some of their parents  are accused of cheering the Indian and Pakistani cricket teams in the UK. And over mounds of artery clogging samosas and pakoras fried in ghee followed by moti choor luddoos and kaju katli they still argue about the one versus two-nation theory.

http://omgies.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/20140819_183219-960x500_c.jpg;https://writegill.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/c60ca-lthree.jpg; http://i.ytimg.com/vi/RaTs6iXFA9Q/maxresdefault.jpg

Thanks to DJ Nihal, that argument can be laid to rest, substituted by the relative merits of butter chicken and palak paneer savouries.

https://encrypted-tbn3.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcQ09tE-glYqXDB51mM2yiPOT0bE7MuLDDVrWt_XhpnqsbzldXkAeA; https://encrypted-tbn3.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcQGkjuFxVMhdjnqenPJ_IxvwGU_R_H-ewOdrPg7XXXJ8y0rJCWg; https://encrypted-tbn1.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSQSD1M1rWR2dXJJKKt93A32ORwuXXUPej7Ez1XLj3JnrI3FW_E

Safer.

Clearer.

No possibility of a cease fire violation — not in the UK — or one may hope!

https://encrypted-tbn2.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcQcJxLe2IPPkKacqGAyt0i4HPxXSDv3xbCngI9dEpW05FpfJom7